Nottebohm (Liechtenstein v. Guatemala)
Cases
Previous
Next
Liechtenstein
See other cases involving
Liechtenstein
Guatemala
See other cases involving
Preliminary objections
Overview of the case
In this case, Liechtenstein claimed restitution and compensation from the Government of Guatemala on the ground that the latter had acted towards Friedrich Nottebohm, a citizen of Liechtenstein, in a manner contrary to international law. Guatemala objected to the Court’s jurisdiction but the Court overruled this objection in a Judgment of 18 November 1953. In a second Judgment, of 6 April 1955, the Court held that Liechtenstein’s claim was inadmissible on grounds relating to Mr. Nottebohm’s nationality. It was the bond of nationality between a State and an individual which alone conferred upon the State the right to put forward an international claim on his behalf. Mr. Nottebohm, who was then a German national, had settled in Guatemala in 1905 and continued to reside there. In October 1939 — after the beginning of the Second World War — while on a visit to Europe, he obtained Liechtenstein nationality and returned to Guatemala in 1940, where he resumed his former business activities until his removal as a result of war measures in 1943. On the international plane, the grant of nationality is entitled to recognition by other States only if it represents a genuine connection between the individual and the State granting its nationality. Mr. Nottebohm’s nationality, however, was not based on any genuine prior link with Liechtenstein and the sole object of his naturalization was to enable him to acquire the status of a neutral national in time of war. For these reasons, Liechtenstein was not entitled to take up his case and put forward an international claim on his behalf against Guatemala.
This overview is provided for information only and in no way involves the responsibility of the Court.
Institution of proceedings
Application instituting proceedings
17 December 1951
Available in:
English
French
Bilingual
Written proceedings
Memorial submitted by the Government of the Principality of Liechtenstein
14 May 1952
Available in:
English
Letter from the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Guatemala to the President of the International Court of Justice
9 September 1952
Procedure(s):
Preliminary objections
Available in:
English
Procedure(s): Preliminary objections
Statement of the Observations of the Government of the Principality of Liechtenstein
11 May 1953
Procedure(s):
Preliminary objections
Available in:
English
Procedure(s): Preliminary objections
Counter-Memorial submitted by the Government of Guatemala
(French version only)
20 April 1954
Available in:
French
(French version only)
Reply submitted by the Government of the Principality of Liechtenstein
14 July 1954
Available in:
English
Rejoinder submitted by the Government of Guatemala
(French version only)
2 November 1954
Available in:
French
(French version only)